Wedding Cake Prices in New York, NY

Wedding Cake Price Guide for New York, NY

Based on our data from 11 bakers in New York, NY, wedding cakes here average $505. The middle 50% of bakers charge between $400 and $575.

Pricing by Tier

Mid-range bakers (3 in New York) average $383. Premium bakers (8 in New York) average $550.

Tips to Save on Your Wedding Cake

• Book during off-peak months (January–March) for potential discounts
• Choose buttercream over fondant — it's usually 20-30% cheaper
• Opt for a simple design with fresh flowers instead of sugar flowers
• Consider a smaller display cake with sheet cake for serving
• Compare quotes from at least 3 bakers before booking