What types of cakes does Cake and Bake offer?

Cake and Bake specializes in custom cakes for all occasions, including wedding cakes, birthday cakes, anniversary cakes, corporate event cakes, and other bespoke creations.

What wedding cake styles do they specialize in?

Cake and Bake crafts a wide range of wedding cake styles, including traditional, modern, rustic, elegant, and fully custom designs to match your unique vision.

Do they offer options for dietary restrictions?

Yes, Cake and Bake offers gluten-free, vegan, and nut-free options. Please discuss your specific dietary needs and allergies during your consultation.

What is the typical lead time for booking a wedding cake?

It is generally recommended to book your wedding cake with Cake and Bake at least 3-4 months in advance, especially during peak wedding seasons, to ensure availability.

What is the estimated price range for their custom cakes?

Cake and Bake offers custom cakes at a competitive price tier. Pricing varies based on size, complexity, and ingredients. Wedding cakes typically start around $400.

Cake and Bake — Wedding Cakes in Milwaukee, WI

What we know about Cake and Bake

Choose Cake and Bake for their exceptional ability to create fully customized cakes that perfectly match your vision. Their commitment to fresh ingredients and artistic design ensures a delicious and beautiful centerpiece for any celebration, backed by a strong reputation in the Milwaukee area.

Location: Milwaukee, WI
Starting price: $400
Book by: 17 weeks ahead
Styles: Custom, Traditional, Modern

About

Cake and Bake, located in Menomonee Falls, WI, serves the greater Milwaukee area with custom-designed cakes for all occasions. With a focus on fresh ingredients and meticulous craftsmanship, this local bakery has earned a strong reputation, reflected in over 90 positive reviews from satisfied clients. They specialize in creating memorable centerpieces that not only look stunning but also taste exquisite, ensuring every celebration is truly special. Cake and Bake prides itself on working closely with each client to bring their unique vision to life, whether for an intimate gathering or a grand event. Their dedication to quality and personalized service makes them a go-to choice for custom confections in Southeastern Wisconsin.

Profile last updated: August 30, 2026

Pricing & Booking

Pricing for custom cakes varies based on design complexity, serving size, and chosen flavors. Wedding cakes generally start from around $400.

Tasting appointments are recommended for wedding and large custom orders. A deposit is typically required to secure your booking date.

Specialties

CustomTraditionalModernRusticElegant

Cake Types

weddingbirthdayanniversarycorporatecustom

Dietary Options

Gluten-free options available

Reviews from couples on WeddingCakes Hub

No reviews yet. Be the first to leave a review!

Leave a Review

Quick Info

Starting at $400$$ Mid-Range · $300–$600

Pricing for custom cakes varies based on design complexity, serving size, and chosen flavors. Wedding cakes generally start from around $400.

Prices vary by design, size & season

LocationMilwaukee, WI

Service Area50 miles

Reviews91

Lead Time17+ weeks

General planning guidance

Wedding Cake Pricing by Season

The general wedding-season demand curve — a guide to when cakes cost more, not Milwaukee, WI pricing or any one baker's rates.

JFMAMJJASOND

Book in January for up to 20% savings on wedding cake pricing.

June and October are peak months — book early for best availability.

PeakShoulderLow Season

Delivery Check

Delivers within 50 miles of Milwaukee, WI

Your venue address or zip code

Cake Planning Timeline

Allergen Safety

Please contact Cake and Bake directly to discuss specific allergen concerns and protocols. While they strive to accommodate dietary needs, cross-contamination is always a possibility in a shared kitchen.

The Story of Cake and Bake

Cake and Bake began with a passion for baking and an artistic flair, blossoming into a beloved local institution in Menomonee Falls, WI. The philosophy behind every creation is simple: a cake should be as delightful to behold as it is to taste. The team believes in using high-quality ingredients to craft desserts that not only serve as the perfect centerpiece but also leave a lasting impression on guests' palates. The signature style of Cake and Bake lies in its versatility and dedication to customization. Rather than adhering to a single aesthetic, they excel at translating each client's unique vision into a tangible, edible masterpiece. Whether it's a multi-tiered wedding cake adorned with intricate sugar flowers or a whimsical birthday creation, their skill in design and execution shines through. Clients consistently praise Cake and Bake for their exceptional customer service, attention to detail, and the deliciousness of their cakes, often remarking on how their expectations were not just met, but exceeded.

Cake and Bake

About

Pricing & Booking

Specialties

Cake Types

Dietary Options

Reviews from couples on WeddingCakes Hub

Leave a Review

Upload Your Cake Photos

Similar Bakers in Milwaukee

cakesbyripal

A Little Slice of Heaven

C. Adam's Bakery

Allergen Safety

The Story of Cake and Bake

Frequently Asked Questions